izpis_h1_title_alt

Participacija učencev v procesu reševanja njihovih učnih težav : doktorska disertacija
ID Kodele, Tadeja (Avtor), ID Lesar, Irena (Mentor) Več o mentorju... Povezava se odpre v novem oknu

URLURL - Predstavitvena datoteka, za dostop obiščite http://pefprints.pef.uni-lj.si/4890/ Povezava se odpre v novem oknu

Izvleček
Participacija otrok v zanje pomembnih zadevah postaja v sodobnem času vse bolj pomemben in zaželen koncept na številnih področjih (npr. v sodnih postopkih, socialnem skrbstvu, šolstvu). Različni avtorji (Hart, 1992; Shier, 2001; Kirby in sod., 2003; Lansdown, 2010) koncepte in stopnjo otrokove participacije različno opredelijo, a vsem je skupno to, da pri oblikovanju opredelitev izhajajo iz 12. člena Konvencije o otrokovih pravicah (1989), ki je države podpisnice zavezala k spoštovanju otrokovih pravic do zaščite, oskrbe in participacije. Avtorji posamezne stopnje participacije opredelijo od stopnje, ko imajo otroci sicer možnost izraziti svoja mnenja o za njih relevantnih procesih, a ni nujno, da so ta upoštevana, do stopnje, ko si otroci z odraslimi delijo moč in odgovornost za sprejemanje zanje relevantnih odločitev, njihova mnenja pa so tudi upoštevana. Vsi avtorji poudarjajo tudi pomen podpore odraslih, kar pomeni, da se otroci lahko v tem procesu vedno obrnejo po pomoč odraslih. Osnovna šola je obvezna za vse in zmožnost participacije je v obstoječi šolski zakonodaji eden od pomembnejših ciljev vzgojno-izobraževalne dejavnosti v Sloveniji (2. člen ZOsn, 2013). Zato je temeljit premislek o omogočanju in spodbujanju participacije še toliko bolj potreben. Prve zametke participacije na področju šolanja lahko sicer zasledimo že na začetku in sredi 20. stoletja, ko so nekateri avtorji (npr. Freire, 1993; Neill, 1999; Dewey, 2012), participacijo učencev vključevali v svoje pedagoško delo. Toda opaznejše spremembe, ki so se kazale tako v spremenjenem načinu poučevanja kot v participatorni vlogi otroka v celotnem pedagoškem procesu, so se v šolskih sistemih začele pojavljati v zadnjih dveh desetletjih prejšnjega stoletja. Kljub zahtevi po zagotavljanju otrokove participacije v procesu odločanja v državah podpisnicah Konvencije o otrokovih pravicah (1989), pa so priložnosti za otrokovo aktivno udeležbo velikokrat odvisne od prepričanj in dobre volje odraslih, ki otroke vključujejo v sprejemanje zanje pomembnih odločitev. Odrasli namreč pogosto ne razumejo, da imajo otroci sposobnosti, s katerimi lahko prispevajo k sprejemanju odločitev, torej podcenjujejo otrokove sposobnosti in ne spoštujejo njihovega mnenja, ker morda tudi ni izraženo na način, ki ustreza odraslim. Če torej želimo, da otrok v šolskem kontekstu participira, so odrasli tisti, ki mu morajo to omogočiti, ga spodbujati in voditi. Za uveljavitev koncepta participacije v šolskem prostoru bi zato bili relevantni predvsem naslednji pedagoški koncepti: pripoznanje otroka kot zmožnega bitja, pedagogika poslušanja, koncept medosebnega prostora, ontološki angažma, koncepti inkluzivnosti in koncept pravičnosti 3 R. Ti koncepti namreč v prvi vrsti izhajajo iz predpostavke, da so učenci kompetentni sogovorniki in sodelavci odraslih. Poleg tega pa opredeljujejo vlogo odraslega (šolskega strokovnega delavca) v odnosu do otroka in poudarjajo, kaj morajo odrasli nenehno reflektirati in zagotavljati, da se otrokova participacija v vsakdanji šolski praksi lahko zgodi. V teoretičnem delu so zato najprej natančno predstavljeni in soočeni ključni koncepti participacije (Hart, 1992; Shier, 2001; Kirby in sod., 2003; Lansdown, 2010) in ovire pri uresničevanju participacije. V nadaljevanju je nemalo pozornosti namenjene razumevanju otroštva in podobe o otroku v preteklosti in danes kot pomembnega dejavnika pri uresničevanju participacije v praksi. Poleg pripoznanja otroka kot zmožnega bitja, so podrobneje predstavljeni še za obravnavano tematiko drugi relevantni koncepti (pedagogika poslušanja, koncept medosebnega prostora, ontološki angažma, koncepti inkluzivnosti in koncept pravičnosti 3 R). Obsežnejše poglavje pa je namenjeno pojavu učnih težav in participaciji učencev v procesu reševanja njihovih učnih težav. V empiričnem delu so najprej predstavljeni izsledki teoretične analize slovenskih formalnih in strokovnih dokumentov s področja osnovnega šolstva, skozi vidik pojmovanja in spodbujanja participacije otrok. V drugem delu raziskave, ki je bil izveden s pomočjo anketnih vprašalnikov med šolskimi svetovalnimi delavkami vseh slovenskih osnovnih šol (n = 189), je narejen pregled stanja o participaciji učencev nasploh, še posebej pa o participaciji učencev z učnimi težavami v procesu reševanja njihovih učnih težav. Ta del raziskave je bil nadgrajen še s kvalitativno analizo, katere namen je bil preko študije primerov na treh izbranih osnovnih šolah podrobneje raziskati odnos šolskih strokovnih delavcev in učencev z učnimi težavami do participacije, kot tudi samo participacijo učencev z učnimi težavami pri identifikaciji učnih težav, pri načrtovanju, izvajanju in evalvaciji učne pomoči ter povezavo med šolsko klimo in omogočanjem participacije učencev z učnimi težavami. Ugotovitve kažejo, da je tako v formalnih in strokovnih dokumentih s področja osnovnega šolstva kot tudi v odgovorih večine anketiranih svetovalnih delavcev opredelitev koncepta participacije precej splošna in neobvezujoča. Zaradi tega je pogosto težko prepoznati in ovrednotiti vlogo učenca v tem procesu, kar posledično pomeni tudi odvisnost participacije učenca od prepričanj in pripravljenosti posameznega šolskega strokovnega delavca, da jo zagotovi. Rezultati so potrdili povezanost med predstavami šolskih strokovnih delavcev o učencih kot kompetentnih sogovornikih in omogočanjem participacije učencev z učnimi težavami. Udeleženci raziskave so učence namreč prepoznavali kot kompetentne sodelavce in sogovornike v procesu reševanja učnih težav, četudi so njihovo kompetentnost večkrat pogojevali z različnimi dejavniki (npr. otrokova starost, zrelost, podpora doma). Prav tako se je kot ena glavnih ovir za participacijo na strani šole pojavila nenaklonjenost participaciji s strani šolskih strokovnih delavcev. Rezultati kažejo tudi na to, da je učinkovitosti učne pomoči v šoli in omogočanje participacije učencev, po poročanju strokovnih delavcev, pogojena s pomočjo, ki so jo učenci deležni doma, od staršev. Glede na rezultate raziskave lahko potrdimo, da obstaja pozitivna povezanost med kulturo institucije in stopnjo participacije učencev z učnimi težavami. Rezultati so pokazali tudi, da šolski strokovni delavci in učenci z učnimi težavami prepoznavajo participacijo kot tisti dejavnik, ki pomembno prispeva k zmanjšanju oz. odpravi učnih težav, večji motivaciji učencev za šolsko delo, bolj učinkoviti učni pomoči. Po drugi strani pa odgovori nekaterih udeležencev raziskave kažejo, da tako participacija učencev na splošno kot tudi učencev z učnimi težavami v procesu reševanja njihovih učnih težav, še vedno ostaja izziv. Poudarja se, da je ključnega pomena pri preseganju tega izziva odnos, ki se v tem procesu vzpostavlja med šolskim strokovnim delavcem in učencem. Oboji so namreč odnos, ki omogoča, da se učenca sliši in upošteva, v katerem učenec pridobi občutek lastne vrednosti in izkusi spoštovanje, prepoznavali kot ključen dejavnik za omogočanje participacije in posledično bolj učinkovite učne pomoči.

Jezik:Slovenski jezik
Ključne besede:učenci z učnimi težavami, pogoji za participacijo, šola, pripoznanje učenca kot zmožnega bitja, prepričanja šolskih strokovnih delavcev
Vrsta gradiva:Doktorsko delo/naloga
Tipologija:2.08 - Doktorska disertacija
Organizacija:PEF - Pedagoška fakulteta
Založnik:[T. Kodele]
Leto izida:2017
Št. strani:286 str.
PID:20.500.12556/RUL-98551 Povezava se odpre v novem oknu
UDK:37(043.3)
COBISS.SI-ID:11847753 Povezava se odpre v novem oknu
Datum objave v RUL:13.12.2017
Število ogledov:2310
Število prenosov:612
Metapodatki:XML DC-XML DC-RDF
:
Kopiraj citat
Objavi na:Bookmark and Share

Sekundarni jezik

Jezik:Angleški jezik
Naslov:Pupils' participation in te process of solving their learning difficulties
Izvleček:
The participation of children in important matters is becoming an increasingly important and desirable concept in many areas in contemporary times (e.g. in court procedures, social care, schools). Various authors (Hart, 1992; Shier, 2001; Kirby et al., 2003; Lansdown, 2010) differentiate the concepts and levels of child’s participation. But when formulating the definitions of this concept they all derive from the Article 12 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989), which obliged the signatory states to respect the child's rights to protection, provision and participation. The authors individual level of participation determine from the degree to which children have the opportunity to express their opinions on relevant processes for them, but they do not necessarily have to be taken into account, to the extent that children with adults share power and responsibility for taking relevant decisions, their opinions are also taken into account. All authors emphasize the importance of adult support, which means that children can always turn to adults for help in this process. Primary school is compulsory for all and the ability to participate in existing school legislation is one of the most important goals of education in Slovenia (Article 2, ZOsn, 2013). Therefore, a thorough reflection on enabling and encouraging participation is necessary. In the early and mid-20th centuries, some authors (e.g. Freire, 1993; Neill, 1999; Dewey, 2012) included the participation of pupils in their pedagogical work. But the more noticeable changes that were reflected in both the changed teaching method and the participatory role of the child throughout the pedagogical process, began to emerge in school systems in the last two decades of the last century. Despite the requirement to provide children with participation in the decision-making process in the countries that are signatories to the Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989), the opportunities for child's active participation are often dependent on the beliefs and goodwill of adults that involve children in making important decisions for them. Adults often do not understand that children have the ability to contribute to decision-making, thus underestimating the child's abilities and disregarding their opinion, because they may not be expressed in a way that suits adults. So if we want children to participate in the school context, we (adults) have to be those who we need to enable it, encourage and lead. In order to apply the concept of participation in the school space, the following pedagogical concepts would be relevant in particular: the recognition of the child as a capable being, the pedagogy of listening, the concept of interpersonal space, ontological engagement, the concepts of inclusiveness and the concept of equity 3 R. These concepts originate first of all from the assumption, that pupils are competent interlocutors and adult’s co-workers. In addition, they define the role of an adult (school professional) in relation to the child and emphasize what adults need to constantly reflect on and ensure that child participation in everyday school practice can occur. In the theoretical part, the key concepts of participation (Hart, 1992; Shier, 2001; Kirby et al., 2003; Lansdown, 2010) and obstacles to the realization of participation are precisely presented. In the following, a lot of attention is devoted to understanding childhood and the image of a child in the past and nowadays as an important factor in realizing participation in practice. In addition to recognizing the child as a capable being, other relevant concepts (pedagogy of listening, concept of interpersonal space, ontological engagement, concepts of inclusiveness and the concept of equity 3 R) are also presented in detail for the topic discussed. A larger chapter is devoted to the phenomenon of learning difficulties and the pupils’ participation in the process of solving their learning difficulties. In the empirical part, the results of the theoretical analysis of Slovene formal and professional documents from the field of primary school are presented first, through the perspective of understanding and encouraging the participation of children. In the second part of the research, which was carried out with the help of questionnaires among school counselors of all Slovenian primary schools (n = 189), an overview of the state of participation of pupils in general was made, and in particular the participation of pupils with learning difficulties in the process of solving their learning problems. This part of the research was further upgraded with a qualitative analysis, which was aimed at researching in more detail the relationship between school professionals and pupils with learning difficulties to participation, as well as the participation of pupils with learning difficulties in identifying learning difficulties, in planning, implementing and evaluating learning help through a case study at three selected primary schools as well the link between the school climate and the participation of the pupils with learning difficulties. The findings show that in both formal and professional documents from the field of primary school, as well as in the answers of the majority of school counsellors, the definition of the concept of participation is rather general and non-binding. For this reason, it is often difficult to recognize and evaluate the role of the pupil in this process, which in turn implies the dependence of pupil’s participation on the beliefs and readiness of a particular school worker to provide it. The results confirmed the correlation between the performance of school professionals about pupils as competent interlocutors and the enabling of participation of pupils with learning difficulties. Participants in the research identified pupils as competent collaborators and interlocutors in the process of solving learning difficulties, although their competence was often conditioned by various factors (e.g. child’s age, maturity, support at home). Similarly, one of the main obstacles to participation on the side of the school was the reluctance of participation by school professionals. The results also show that the effectiveness of learning help at school and the enabling of pupils' participation, according to school professionals, are conditioned by the help pupils receive at home from their parents. According to the results of the research, we can confirm that there is a positive correlation between the institution's culture and the level of participation of pupils with learning difficulties. The results also show that school professionals and pupils with learning difficulties recognize participation as the factor that significantly contributes to the reduction or decrease of learning difficulties, increase students' motivation for school work, and more effective learning help. On the other hand, the answers of some research participants show that both the participation of pupils in general as well as the pupils with learning difficulties in the process of solving their learning problems remains a challenge. It is stressed that the key to overcoming this challenge is the relationship that is being established in this process between a school professional and a pupil. They both recognize the relationship that enables the pupil to be heard and taken into account, in which a pupil acquires a sense of self-worth and experiences respect, as a key factor in facilitating participation and, consequently, more effective learning help.

Ključne besede:participation, learning difficulty, pupil, soodločanje, učne težave, učenec

Podobna dela

Podobna dela v RUL:
Podobna dela v drugih slovenskih zbirkah:

Nazaj