This master’s thesis examined the medicalisation of the ways in which children with special educational needs are understood and responded to within the Slovenian education system. It proceeded from the premise that medicalisation cannot be reduced to diagnostic practices or the use of medical categories, but must be analysed within a broader social, institutional and pedagogical context. The aim was to explore how societal and school norms influence the identification of deviations, how professionals interpret children’s difficulties, and how these interpretations guide responses to those difficulties. Particular attention was paid to the construction of school success, discourses concerning children with special educational needs, the Slovenian system of educational placement and individualised support, and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) as an analytical case.
Drawing on an analysis of scholarly and professional literature, as well as official and other relevant documents, the thesis examined the issue at three interconnected levels. At the broader societal level, it explored social norms, the evaluation of school success, and changes in contemporary education. At the institutional level, it examined the organisation of provision for children with special educational needs within the Slovenian education system. Through the case of ADHD, it explored the relationship between children’s characteristics, environmental expectations, diagnostic practices and forms of support.
The analysis showed that school norms concerning achievement and behaviour provide an important framework within which certain differences between pupils come to be recognised as deviations. This does not, however, establish a direct causal relationship between school demands and increasing rates of diagnosis. Within the formal framework of the Slovenian system, the analysis identified an interplay between the discourse of rights, professional or medical discourse, and pedagogical discourse in practice. Diagnosis, educational placement and individualised professional support can enable children’s needs to be recognised, their rights to be exercised and support to be accessed. Individualised support therefore cannot be equated with the individualisation of the problem.
The principal finding is that medicalisation cannot be understood as a consequence of diagnosis or professional intervention, but rather as a potential process involving the interplay of social norms, professional interpretations and institutional practices. A medicalising logic is particularly evident when children’s difficulties and limitations in functioning are explained predominantly in terms of an individual deficit or pathology, while pedagogical, relational and institutional circumstances receive less critical scrutiny. The thesis therefore does not advocate abandoning diagnostic assessment or individualised support. Rather, it emphasises the importance of distinguishing between the individualisation of support and the individualisation of the problem, alongside the responsibility of the educational environment to create conditions that enable children’s inclusion and functioning.
|