The article examines the dilemma frontline emergency officials face in balancing strict adherence to rules with the need for discretion in crisis situations. Focusing on "infra-law" - a set of informal, flexible regulations specific to street-level bureaucracy - the author proposes that infra-law can moderate the discretion exercised by these officials. Given that emergencies are inherently unpredictable and urgent, he argues that strict rule-following often fails, making discretion necessary for effective crisis response. However, excessive discretion risks inconsistency and arbitrariness, undermining legality and public trust. Infra-law, typically embodied in directives, protocols, or internal guidelines, offers a middle ground. By providing a real-time guidance adaptable to the unique demands of specific emergencies, infra-law helps align frontline actions with overarching legal and organisational frameworks while respecting the practical realities of emergency decision-making. This framework, supported by organisational disciplinary power, aims to limit arbitrariness and maintain legality, ensuring that emergency responses remain both flexible and accountable.
|