Details

Meje spreminjanja opisa kaznivega dejanja iz obtožnega akta v sodbi : napolnjevanje zahteve po objektivni identiteti med obtožbo in sodbo
ID Briški, Lora (Author)

.pdfPDF - Presentation file, Download (325,93 KB)
MD5: A0CEEE6D7CC304A02F3C0B843CEBF3EC

Abstract
Posledica obtožnega načela (19. člen ZKP) je zahteva po objektivni identiteti med obtožbo in sodbo (354. člen ZKP), ki pomeni, da se sme sodba nanašati samo na dejanje, ki ga tožilec opiše v obtožnem aktu. Pomen te zahteve je dvojen. Prvič, s tem ko sme sodišče odločati samo o dejanju, za katerega je tožilec obtožil, ostajata procesni funkciji obtoževanja in odločanja o obtožbi ločeni, kar je prvi pogoj za nepristransko sojenje. Drugič, obdolžencu omogoča, da na podlagi očitka iz obtožbe organizira svojo obrambo. Če bi namreč sodišče obdolženca obsodilo za drugo dejanje, bi mu odvzelo možnost, da se zoper obtožbo učinkovito brani. Avtorica preučuje, ali sme sodišče, ki na glavni obravnavi ugotovi, da se dejanje kaže v drugačni luči, kot ga je opisal tožilec, opis prilagoditi, ne da bi pri tem stopilo v čevlje tožilstva. Nanj odgovarja upoštevaje spoznanja slovenske teorije in na podlagi analize sodne prakse, ki zahtevo o objektivni identiteti obtožbe in sodbe napolnjuje v konkretnih primerih.

Language:Slovenian
Keywords:identiteta obtožbe in sodbe, objektivna identiteta, obtožno načelo, sprememba opisa kaznivega dejanja, pravica do seznanitve z obtožbo, ločitev procesnih funkcij
Work type:Article
Typology:1.01 - Original Scientific Article
Organization:PF - Faculty of Law
Publication status:Published
Publication version:Version of Record
Year:2025
Number of pages:Str. 79-101, 123-124
Numbering:Letn. 80 (142), št. 1/2
PID:20.500.12556/RUL-191324 This link opens in a new window
UDC:343:347.95(497.4)
ISSN on article:0032-6976
COBISS.SI-ID:228294147 This link opens in a new window
Publication date in RUL:16.11.2026
Views:15
Downloads:1
Metadata:XML DC-XML DC-RDF
:
Copy citation
Share:Bookmark and Share

Record is a part of a journal

Title:Pravnik : revija za pravno teorijo in prakso
Shortened title:Pravnik
Publisher:Zveza društev pravnikov Slovenije
ISSN:0032-6976
COBISS.SI-ID:14114304 This link opens in a new window

Secondary language

Language:English
Title:The limits of modifying the description of the criminal offence from the indictment in the judgment
Abstract:
A corollary of the accusatorial principle (Article 19 of the Criminal Procedure Act – CPA) is the requirement of objective identity between the charge and the judgment (Article 354 of the CPA). This requirement mandates that the judgment may be based solely on the act described by the prosecutor in the indictment. The significance of this requirement is twofold. First, by limiting the court’s judgment to the act charged by the prosecutor, it preserves the separation between the procedural functions of charging and deciding on the charge, which is essential for ensuring an impartial trial. Second, it allows the accused to organise their defence based on a specific charge brought against them. If the court were to convict the accused of a different offence, it would deprive them of the opportunity to organise an appropriate defence. In this article, I examine whether a court that perceives an act differently during the trial from how the prosecutor described it in the indictment may adjust the description without overstepping into the prosecution’s role. I explore this question by considering the insights of Slovenian legal theory and by analysing case law that interprets the requirement of objective identity between the charge and the judgment in specific cases.

Keywords:identity of the charge and the judgment, objective identity, accusatorial principle, modification of the description of the offence, right to be informed of the accusation, separation of procedural functions

Similar documents

Similar works from RUL:
Similar works from other Slovenian collections:

Collection

This document is a part of these collections:
  1. Pravnik

Back