Rule of law and democratic decline during states of emergency – the case of the Czech Republic

Janderová, Jana (author)

Purpose: This paper analyses the impact of the state of emergency declared during the Covid-19 pandemic on public administration, specifically focusing on the Czech Republic. It aims to understand the correlation between the rule of law, the legitimacy of measures taken during the pandemic, and the public’s willingness to comply with these measures. Design/Methodology/Approach: The paper employs a comparative study design, examining the consistency of pandemic measures with the core principles of the rule of law – legality, proportionality, and legitimate expectations. The study focuses on measures that restrict rights (e.g., right to education) and those that, conversely, grant rights (e.g., decisions on compensation bonuses). The methodology involves an analysis of the relevant case law, administrative practice, and data from several databases. Findings: The study reveals frequent breaches of legality and proportionality, both in the restriction and granting of rights. Findings indicate that the public’s willingness to comply with measures decreased when these were perceived as illegitimate. This was evident in the Czech Republic where, despite the persistence of most measures, the situation worsened during the autumn 2020 and spring 2021 waves of the pandemic. Practical Implications: The findings of this study have significant implications for public administration and policymaking, especially during times of crisis and declared state of emergency. The results highlight the importance of maintaining the rule of law and ensuring the legitimacy of public compliance measures. The study suggests that disregard for these principles can lead to a decline in public trust and cooperation, exacerbating the crisis. Originality/Value: This paper provides a unique perspective on the management of the Covid-19 pandemic, linking the rule of law with public compliance. It offers valuable insights for governments and policymakers on the importance of maintaining legality and proportionality in their measures, and the potential consequences of their disregard. What sets this study apart is its comprehensive analysis of both cases where rights were reduced (such as limitations of the right to education) and cases where rights were provided (such as the granting of compensation bonuses). This dual-focused approach offers a more holistic view of the impact of governmental measures during the pandemic. The study’s findings contribute to the broader understanding of crisis management and the role of public administration. This comprehensive approach enhances the originality and value of the research, making it a significant contribution to the field.

• Language: English
• Keywords: compensation bonus, democratic decline, state of emergency, proportionality, right to education, rule of law
• Work type: Article
• Typology: 1.01 - Original Scientific Article
• Organization: FU - Faculty of Administration
• Publication status: Published
• Publication version: Version of Record
• Year: 2024
• Number of pages: Str. 55-77, 254-255
• Numbering: Vol. 22, iss. 2
• PID: 20.500.12556/RUL-165641
• UDC: 32:342.77(437.3)
• ISSN on article: 2591-2240
• DOI: 10.17573/cepar.2024.2.03
• COBISS.SI-ID: 218354691
• Publication date in RUL: 11.12.2024

Record is a part of a journal

• Title: Central European public administration review
• Shortened title: CEPAR
• Publisher: Fakulteta za upravo
• ISSN: 2591-2240
• COBISS.SI-ID: 293849600

Licences

• License: CC BY-SA 4.0, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International
• Link: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
• Description: This Creative Commons license is very similar to the regular Attribution license, but requires the release of all derivative works under this same license.

Secondary language

• Language: Slovenian
• Title: Pravna država in upad demokracije v času izrednih razmer – primer Češke republike

Abstract

Namen: Prispevek analizira vpliv izrednih razmer, razglašenih med pandemijo covida-19, na javno upravo, zlasti na Češkem. Njegov namen je razumeti povezavo med pravno državo, legitimnostjo ukrepov, sprejetih med pandemijo, in pripravljenostjo javnosti, da te ukrepe spoštuje. Zasnova/metodologija/pristop: Uporabljena je primerjalna študija, ki proučuje skladnost ukrepov ob pandemiji s temeljnimi načeli pravne države – zakonitostjo, sorazmernostjo in legitimnimi pričakovanji. Študija se osredotoča na ukrepe, ki pravice (npr. pravico do izobraževanja) omejujejo, in tiste, ki, nasprotno, pravice dodeljujejo (npr. nadomestila). Metodologija vključuje analizo ustrezne sodne prakse, upravne prakse in podatkov iz več podatkovnih zbirk. Ugotovitve: Študija razkriva pogoste kršitve načel zakonitosti in sorazmernosti, tako pri omejevanju kot pri dodeljevanju pravic. Ugotovitve kažejo, da se je pripravljenost javnosti za upoštevanje ukrepov zmanjšala, če so bili ti zaznani kot protizakoniti. To se je pokazalo tudi na Češkem, kjer so se ob vztrajanju večine ukrepov jeseni 2020 in spomladi 2021 razmere poslabšale. Praktične posledice: Ugotovitve te študije imajo pomembne posledice za javno upravo in oblikovanje politik, zlasti v času krize in razglašenih izrednih razmer. Rezultati poudarjajo pomen ohranjanja pravne države in zagotavljanja legitimnosti ukrepov. Študija nakazuje, da lahko neupoštevanje teh načel povzroči upad javnega zaupanja in sodelovanja, kar krizo še dodatno stopnjuje. Izvirnost/vrednost: Prispevek ponuja edinstven pogled na obvladovanje pandemije covida-19, saj povezuje pravno državo in spoštovanje ukrepov s strani javnosti. Vladam in oblikovalcem politik ponuja dragocen vpogled v pomen ohranjanja zakonitosti in sorazmernosti pri ukrepih ter v morebitne posledice neupoštevanja teh načel. Izvirnost študije se kaže v tem, da celovito analizira tako primere krčenja pravic (npr. omejitev pravice do izobraževanja) kot primere dodeljevanja pravic (npr. nadomestila). Tovrsten pristop omogoča celovitejše razumevanje učinka vladnih ukrepov med pandemijo. Ugotovitve študije prispevajo k širšemu razumevanju kriznega upravljanja in vloge javne uprave.

• Keywords: nadomestilo, upad demokracije, izredne razmere, sorazmernost, pravica do izobraževanja, pravna država

Projects

• Funder: Other - Other funder or multiple funders
• Funding programme: Czech Republic
• Project number: SGS_2022_017
• Name: Selected aspects of the development of economies and financial markets in the pandemic and post-pandemic era