Resničnost in estetika v dokumentarni fotografiji : diplomsko delo

Zorenč, Verena (author), Selan, Jurij (mentor), Podobnik, Uršula (comentor)

Želja človeka, da bi si lastil trenutek, ne ozirajoč se na njegovo minljivost, je bila izpolnjena z izumom fotografske kamere. V diplomskem delu sem se osredotočila na dokumentarno fotografijo ter njeno estetsko vrednost. Raziskala sem, kako se je razvoj dokumentacije razvijal skozi likovne medije, zlasti slikarstvo, v različnih zgodovinskih obdobjih in kakšno vlogo je imela fotografija kasneje, v službi dokumentacije. Pri samem raziskovanju so me vodila vprašanja o insceniranosti fotografije in njen vpliv na dokumentarno in sporočilno vrednost. Tematsko sem se osredotočila na socialno angažirano fotografijo, ki dokumentira tako življenja ljudi iz roba družbe kot tudi prizore trpljenja. Od fotografov, ki so se osredotočali na bedo in stisko ljudi sem izbrala Lewisa Hina in predstavila njegovo delo. Zadrževalno moč prizorov trpljenja sem primerjala s tisto, ki si jo lastijo tudi pornografske podobe, pri tem pa sem, predvsem skozi posnetke iz zapora Abu Graib, prikazala možnost zlorabe fotografije, ko le ta svojo dokumentacijsko vlogo zamenja za vlogo glavnega povoda za dogodek sam. Tu sem hkrati odprla tudi vprašanje o prezenci in distanci, torej o razliki doživljanja dogodka v živo oziroma preko fotografije. Še zlasti pa me je zanimalo, kaj je tisti element, preko katerega se določena dokumentarna fotografija loči od preostalih, kaj je tisto kar jo dela zapomljivo. Na to vprašanje sem odgovarjala skozi likovne analize posameznih fotografskih del in pri tem raziskovala ter poglabljala Barthovski koncept punctuma. Kljub izjemni razširjenosti fotografskega medija kot sredstva likovnega izražanja, pa ji šolski sistem pri predmetu likovne umetnosti ne namenja dosti pozornosti. V pedagoškem delu sem del teoretičnega dela prenesla v pedagoško prakso, kjer so učenci pri likovni nalogi posneli fotografijo s poljubno socialno tematiko. Eno od del, ki so nastala skozi učno uro, sem tudi podrobneje predstavila.

• Language: Slovenian
• Keywords: plezanje, blagovne znamke, podjetništvo, trženje, učna priprava
• Work type: Undergraduate thesis
• Typology: 2.11 - Undergraduate Thesis
• Organization: PEF - Faculty of Education
• Publisher: [V. Zorenč]
• Year: 2014
• Number of pages: VI, 119 f.
• PID: 20.500.12556/RUL-69209
• UDC: 77.03:7.01:111.852(043.2)
• COBISS.SI-ID: 10263881
• Publication date in RUL: 10.07.2015

Secondary language

• Language: English
• Title: Reality and aesthetics of documentary photography

Abstract

The human desire to seize the moment, regardless of its fleetingness, had been fulfilled with the invention of a photographic camera. In my dissertation I focused on the documentary photography and its aesthetical value. I explored how the documentary research has been developing through visual media, especially painting, in different time periods; furthermore, I looked at the role the photography had in more modern history of documentation. My research was guided by the problem of photography staging and how that influences its documentary and communicative value. Thematically, I was interested mainly in the social photography, which documents the life of people from the edge of society as well as the scenes of horror and misery. Amongst the photographers focusing on aforementioned sights of humans’ squalor, I've chosen Lewis Hine and presented his work. I compared the captivating power of the scenes of great suffering with the one also possessed by pornographic pictures; at the same time, I've used the photos from the Abu Ghraib prison to show how photography can be abused, when it switches its documentary role to being the main reason for the incident itself. At this point, I presented the issue of 'presence and distance', the difference of actually witnessing an event in real life to observing it on a photo. One of my main interests was also, what is that very thing that makes some documentary photography so memorable and distinguishes it from the rest. I tried to answer that question through visual analysis of several photography works while researching and deepening the Barthes’ concept of punctum. Despite the exceptional popularity of photography medium as the manner of visual expression, it is too often overlooked at the art lessons in contemporary school system. In the pedagogic part of my dissertation I tried to implement a part of my theoretical research into pedagogical practice. A group of school children was given an art assignment to take a photograph with a social theme of their choice. In the end I made the detailed analyses of one of the photos made during the lesson.