izpis_h1_title_alt

Oblikovanje in ovrednotenje učnega modela za zvišanje ravni tehnološke pismenosti učencev 8. razreda osnovne šole : doktorska disertacija
ID Rupnik, Denis (Author), ID Avsec, Stanislav (Mentor) More about this mentor... This link opens in a new window

.pdfPDF - Presentation file, Download (3,52 MB)
MD5: A1FA6094620F40F46B729206C13E76B7

Abstract
Tehniško izobraževanje (TI) predstavlja izobraževanje vsebin tehnike in tehnologije (TiT) za učence/dijake/študente od osnovnošolskega (OŠ) do univerzitetnega študija z namenom biti tehnološko pismen. Tehnološko pismen učenec bo znal uporabiti deklarativno in procesno tehnološko znanje; imel bo veščine za reševanje tehnoloških problemov in bo skupaj s pozitivnim in kritičnem odnosom do vsebin TiT sposoben tudi kritičnega razmišljanja in odločanja o uporabi, ravnanju in presoji/oceni tehnologij. Višja raven tehnološke pismenosti (TP) odločilno vpliva na nadaljnjo šolanje na področju tehnike in inženirstva, kot tudi na učinkovito soočanje s trenutnimi tehnološkim spremembami. Namen dela je bil proučiti, kako taksonomsko diferencirano problemsko ponavljanje/utrjevanje/obravnava usvojenih učnih vsebin vplivajo na zvišanje ravni TP. Ugotovljeno je bilo tudi, katera znanja, veščine, sposobnosti in dimenzije TP so bile s pomočjo dvonivojskega modela izboljšane. Na 1. nivoju se je to izvajalo s pomočjo vnaprej pripravljenega učnega modela, sestavljenega iz nalog z nižjo stopnjo težavnosti posamezne taksonomske stopnje, medtem ko je 2. nivo za razliko od prvega sestavljen iz nalog z višjo stopnjo težavnosti posamezne taksonomske stopnje. Kot referenčno skupino smo uporabili tradicionalni pouk, ki vključuje ponavljanje/utrjevanje/obravnavo na način, ki ga učitelji običajno uporabljajo. Z namenom ugotovitve stanja TP na začetku pouka TiT v 6. razredu in ob zaključku pouka rednih vsebin TiT v 8. razredu OŠ smo v sklopu pilotne raziskave izvedli presečno raziskavo odnosa do TiT in TP. Domnevali smo, da je odnos do TiT lahko odločilnega pomena pri razvoju TP, zato smo preverili tudi stanje odnosa do tehnike učencev v 6. in 8. razredu. Še več: poskušali smo ugotoviti tudi možno napovedno vrednost odnosa do TiT za doseganje ravni znanja, zmožnosti in kritičnega razmišljanja in odločanja (KRO) kot dimenzij TP. V pilotno raziskavo so bili vključeni učenci 6. razreda (n = 86) ter učenci 8. razreda (n = 94). V disertaciji predstavljamo rezultate, da so učenci 8. razreda dosegli boljše rezultate kot učenci 6. razreda v TP. Pomembna razlika je bila ugotovljena pri dimenziji KRO, kjer so učenci 8. razreda na testu KRO dosegli višje rezultate kot učenci 6. razreda. Po spolu nismo ugotovili nobenih pomembnih razlik v uspešnosti dimenzij TP, zmožnosti in KRO, medtem ko smo pri dimenziji znanje ugotovili pomembno razliko v 6. razredu, kjer so učenke dosegle boljše rezultate kot učenci. Pri merjenju odnosa do tehnike smo ugotovili, da se zdi, da se učenci zavedajo posledic TiT na družbo in imajo pozitivno mnenje o pomembnosti pouka TiT v rednem učnem načrtu (UN). Učenci so bili prepričani, da so za TiT naloge ali poklice sposobnejši od učenk. Presenetljivo je, da učenci ne ocenjujejo TiT kot težavnih ter da je odnos učencev 6. razreda do zanimanja za TiT višji kot pri učencih iz 8. razreda. Rezultati pilotne raziskave so kazali na smiselnost implementacije novih učnih modelov za dvig ravni TP v 8. razredu, kjer je nivo KRO statistično pomembno višji kot v 6. in bi lahko omogočil želene učinke pouka TiT po uvedbi novih modelov. Opravili smo raziskavo, ki je bila izvedena v petih OŠ v različno velikih občinah v različnih mestnih in podeželskih območjih v Sloveniji. V raziskavo so bili vključeni učenci 8. razreda OŠ (n = 242) in učitelji TiT (n = 5). Glede na zasnovo raziskave je bil vzorec razdeljen na tri glavne skupine, kjer je bil eksperiment izveden v dveh skupinah: (1) 1. nivo (65 učencev; 30 učenk, 35 učencev) in (2) 2. nivo (94 učencev; 46 učenk, 48 učencev), medtem ko je bila kontrolna skupina ena (83 učencev; 46 učenk, 37 učencev). V raziskavi je bilo ugotovljeno, kakšna je bila raven TP učencev 8. razreda osnovne šole (OŠ) na začetku šolskega leta in za koliko se je učencem spremenila raven TP v času enega šolskega leta po vpeljavi novo zasnovanega učnega modela za zvišanje ravni TP. Ugotovili smo, da imajo interdisciplinarni pristopi statistično pomemben vpliv na pridobivanje TP s pozitivno in veliko velikostjo učinka. Obe eksperimentalni skupini se bistveno ne razlikujeta. Presenetljivo se pojavi tudi statistično pomembna razlika v odporu učencev do TiT, in sicer pri modelu na 2. nivoju, kjer so vsebine višjega kognitivnega nivoja. To lahko interpretiramo z dejstvom, da učenci do sedaj niso bili deležni pouka na nivojih višje od 3. Bloomove taksonomske ravni in si verjetno še ne znajo razložiti pomena obravnave snovi na višjih taksonomskih stopnjah ter so verjetno pričakovali večjo pomoč od učitelja. Raziskovali smo tudi korelacije med uporabo novo zasnovanega učnega modela ter njihovimi vplivi na posamezne dimenzije TP. Ugotovitve in dognanja raziskave bodo pomembno prispevali k načrtovanju kakovostnega TI v OŠ, ki bo usmerjeno h krepitvi TP učencev. Znanstveni doprinos doktorskega dela je pojasnitev ključnih dejavnikov TP in boljše razumevanje TP za optimizacijo TI.

Language:Slovenian
Keywords:Tehniško izobraževanje, Tehnološka pismenost, Osnovnošolsko učenje in poučevanje, Tehnika, tehnika in tehnologija, problemski pouk
Work type:Doctoral dissertation
Typology:2.08 - Doctoral Dissertation
Organization:PEF - Faculty of Education
Place of publishing:Ljubljana
Publisher:D. Rupnik
Year:2024
Number of pages:XVII, 187, LV str.
PID:20.500.12556/RUL-161410 This link opens in a new window
UDC:373.3:62(043.2)
COBISS.SI-ID:207252227 This link opens in a new window
Publication date in RUL:11.09.2024
Views:160
Downloads:34
Metadata:XML DC-XML DC-RDF
:
Copy citation
Share:Bookmark and Share

Secondary language

Language:English
Title:Designing and evaluating an instructional model to enhance eighth-grade pupils' technological literacy
Abstract:
Engineering education is the education of engineering and technology (EaT) content for pupils/students from primary school to university studies to be technologically literate. A technologically literate pupil will be able to apply declarative and procedural technological knowledge, have the skills to solve technological problems, and together with a positive and critical attitude towards engineering and technology content, also be able to think critically and make decisions about the use, conduct, and judgment/appraisal of technologies. A higher level of Technological Literacy (TL) has a decisive influence on further education in the field of technology and engineering, as well as on effectively coping with current technological change. This dissertation aimed to investigate how taxonomically differentiated problem-based repetition/reinforcement/treatment of learned learning content influences the increase in TL level. It was also found that knowledge, skills, abilities, and dimensions of TL were enhanced by the multi-stage model. In stage 1, this was done using a pre-prepared learning model consisting of tasks with a lower level of difficulty per taxonomic level. Stage 2, unlike stage 1, consists of tasks with a higher level of difficulty per taxonomic level. Stage 3 of the model involves repetition/reinforcement in the manner commonly used by teachers. A cross-sectional survey of attitudes towards EaT and TL was conducted as part of a pilot study to determine the state of TL at the beginning of EaT in grade 6 and at the end of regular EaT content in grade 8 of elementary school. We hypothesized that attitudes towards EaT may be crucial for the development of TL and we also examined the state of pupils' attitudes towards technology in grade 6 and grade 8. Moreover, we also sought to identify the possible predictive value of attitudes towards EaT for the achievement of knowledge, skills, and critical thinking and decision-making (CTDM) as dimensions of TL. The pilot study included grade 6 pupils (n = 86) and grade 8 pupils (n = 94). In this dissertation, we present the results that grade 8 pupils outperformed grade 6 pupils in TL. A significant difference was found in the CTDM dimension where grade 8 pupils scored higher than grade 6 pupils on the CTDM test. No significant gender differences were found in the performance on the TL, ability, and CTDM dimensions while on the knowledge dimension, a significant difference was found in grade 6 where female pupils outperformed male students. When measuring attitudes towards technology, we found that pupils seem to be aware of the implications of EaT on society and have a positive view of the importance of EaT in mainstream UN. Male pupils were more confident than female pupils that they were more capable than female pupils for EaT tasks or occupations. It is surprising that pupils do not rate EaT as difficult and that the attitude of grade 6 pupils towards interest in EaT is higher than that of grade 8 pupils. The results of the pilot study indicated that it is reasonable to implement new learning models to raise the level of EaT in grade 8 where the level of CTDM is statistically significantly higher than in grade 6 and could provide the desired effects of EaT instruction after the introduction of the new models. We carried out a study in five elementary schools in different-sized municipalities in different urban and rural areas in Slovenia. The participants were 8th-grade pupils of elementary schools (n = 242) and EaT teachers (n = 5). According to the research design, the sample was divided into three main groups where the experiment was conducted in two groups: (1) Level 1 (65 pupils; 30 females, 35 males) and (2) Level 2 (94 pupils; 46 females, 48 males) while the control group was one (83 pupils; 46 females, 37 males). The study investigated the TL level of 8th-grade pupils in elementary school (elementary school) and how much the pupils' TL level changed over one school year after the implementation of a newly designed instructional model to increase the TL level. We found that interdisciplinary approaches have a statistically significant impact on the acquisition of TLs with positive and large effect sizes. The two experimental groups are not significantly different. Surprisingly, there is also a statistically significant difference in pupils' resistance to EaT, namely in the Level 2 model where the content is of a higher cognitive level. This can be interpreted by the fact that pupils have not yet received instruction at levels higher than Bloom's taxonomy level 3 and are probably not yet able to explain the meaning of dealing with the material at higher taxonomic levels and probably expect more help from the teacher. We also explored correlations between the use of the newly designed learning model and their effects on individual TL dimensions. The findings and implications of the research will contribute significantly to the design of quality engineering education in elementary schools which will be geared towards enhancing pupils' TL. The scientific contribution of the Ph.D. thesis is the clarification of the key determinants of TL and a better understanding of TL for optimizing engineering education.

Keywords:technology education, technological literacy, engineering and technology, problem-based learning

Similar documents

Similar works from RUL:
Similar works from other Slovenian collections:

Back