izpis_h1_title_alt

Scientometric indicators : peer-review, bibliometric methods and conflict of interests
Južnič, Primož (Avtor), Pečlin, Stojan (Avtor), Žaucer, Matjaž (Avtor), Mandelj, Tilen (Avtor), Pušnik, Miro (Avtor), Demšar, Franci (Avtor)

URLURL - Predstavitvena datoteka, za dostop obiščite http://www.springerlink.com/content/u76424w3579n06j5/fulltext.html Novo okno

Izvleček
The paper discusses the role of scientometric indicators in peer-review selection of research project proposals. An ex post facto evaluation was made of three calls for research project proposals in Slovenia: 2003 with a peer review system designed in a way that conflict of interest was not avoided effectively, 2005 with a sound international peer-review system with minimized conflict of interest influence but a limited number of reviewers, and 2008 with a combination of scientometric indicators and a sound international peer review with minimized conflict of interest influence. The hypothesis was that the three different peer review systems would have different correlations with the same set of scientometric indicators. In the last two decision-making systems (2005 and 2008) where conflict of interest was effectively avoided, we have a high percentage (65%) of projects that would have been selected in the call irrespective of the method (peer review or bibliometrics solely). In contrast, in the 2003 call there is a significantly smaller percentage (49%) of projects that would have been selected in the call irrespective of the method (peer review or bibliometrics solely). It was shown that while scientometric indicators can hardly replace the peer-review system as the ultimate decision-making and support system, they can reveal its weaknesses on one hand and on the other can verify peer-review scores and minimize conflict of interest if necessary.

Jezik:Angleški jezik
Ključne besede:scientometrija, indikatorji, ovrednotenje, raziskovalni projekti, scientometric indicators, peer-review, research project proposals, evaluations, decision making systems
Vrsta gradiva:Delo ni kategorizirano (r6)
Tipologija:1.01 - Izvirni znanstveni članek
Organizacija:FF - Filozofska fakulteta
Leto izida:2010
Št. strani:str. [429]-441
Številčenje:Vol. 85, no. 2
UDK:001.89:3(497.4)
ISSN pri članku:0138-9130
DOI:10.1007/s11192-010-0230-8 Povezava se odpre v novem oknu
COBISS.SI-ID:42424418 Povezava se odpre v novem oknu
Število ogledov:584
Število prenosov:230
Metapodatki:XML RDF-CHPDL DC-XML DC-RDF
 
Skupna ocena:(0 glasov)
Vaša ocena:Ocenjevanje je dovoljeno samo prijavljenim uporabnikom.
:
Objavi na: Bookmark and Share

Gradivo je del revije

Naslov:Scientometrics
Skrajšan naslov:Scientometrics
Založnik:Elsevier, Akadémiai Kiadó
ISSN:0138-9130
COBISS.SI-ID:1252362 Novo okno

Podobna dela

Podobna dela v RUL:
Podobna dela v drugih slovenskih zbirkah:

Komentarji

Dodaj komentar

Za komentiranje se morate prijaviti.

Komentarji (0)
0 - 0 / 0
 
Ni komentarjev!

Nazaj