20.500.12556/RUL-85430 The case-orientedness of qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) glass half-empty or half-full? This article addresses the development of Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) from its launching in 1987 until present. We surveyed from the perspective of QCA's proclaimed "case-orientedness". We started by examining the foundations of QCA and the way those foundations have evolved over three decennia, in particular in terms of the connection with case-oriented work. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this was and is still an important facet of QCA both as an approach and as a set of techniques. Additionally, in more concrete terms, we go through all the practical QCA operations and demonstrate that virtually in every step of the QCA procedure; there is a potential dialogue with the individual cases, whether they are defined at the macro-, meso- or micro levels. Finally, we analyze the current state of affairs which seems to run against the articulation between "deep" (in particular ethnographic) case-oriented work and QCA, and propose avenues to engage more thoroughly in deeper case-informed QCA work. Članek prikaže pregled razvoja kvalitativne primerjalne analize (QCA) od njenih začetkov leta 1987 do aktualnih dosežkov. Njen razvoj analiziramo z vidika ključnega vodila te metode, in sicer z vidika usmerjenosti k primerom. Uvodoma preučimo konceptualno podstat QCA ter konceptualne spremembe skozi zadnja tri desetletja njene uporabe. Osredotočimo se predvsem na napredek pri metodi, ki obravnava njeno jedro "usmerjenost k primerom". Prikažemo, da je to bilo in je še vedno pomembno vodilo razvoja kvalitativne primerjalne metode kot raziskovalnega pristopa in kot tehnike. V nadaljevanju obravnavamo konkretne korake praktične aplikacije QCA in njenih operacij ter demonstriramo, da je v prav vsakem koraku QCA postopka zaznati potencialni dialog s posameznimi primeri, pa naj bodo opredeljeni na makro-, mezo- ali mikroravni. V zadnjem delu pregledamo trenutno prakso uporabe te metode, ki kaže na razkorak med možnim poglobljenim (predvsem v etnografskem smislu) delom, usmerjenim k primerom v aplikacijah QCA, in konceptualno usmerjenostjo k primerom v QCA. Predlagamo nekaj razvojnih smeri, ki vodijo k bolj podrobni in poglobljeni usmerjenosti k primerom v delu s QCA. primerjalne metode true false false Angleški jezik Slovenski jezik Delo ni kategorizirano 2016-09-15 03:38:00 2016-09-20 10:26:29 2022-08-03 03:41:36 0000-00-00 00:00:00 2015 0 0 Str. 1039-1055, 1244-1245 št. 6 Letn. 52 nov.-dec. 2015 0000-00-00 NiDoloceno NiDoloceno NiDoloceno 0000-00-00 0000-00-00 0000-00-00 311.1 0040-3598 33784157 763652 http://dk.fdv.uni-lj.si/db/pdfs/TiP2015_6_RihouxLobe.pdf 1 https://repozitorij.uni-lj.si/Dokument.php?lang=slv&id=88548 Fakulteta za družbene vede 0 0 0