20.500.12556/RUL-150637 Pravica do izjave v postopku dodelitve mednarodne zaščite magistrsko diplomsko delo The right to be heard in the procedure for granting international protection Magistrsko diplomsko delo preučuje vsebino pravice do izjave, ki tvori sestavni del azilnega postopka. Osredotoča se na njeno vsebino, ki izhaja iz primarnega in sekundarnega prava Evropske unije. To dopolnjuje s sodno prakso sodišča Evropske unije, Evropskega sodišča za človekove pravice in priporočila nekaterih drugih upoštevnih mednarodnih organov. Delo analizira procesne garancije, ki izhajajo iz pravice, glede na stopnjo, v katerem je postopek, ob upoštevanju procesne dimenzije načela nevračanja. Obravnava pogoje osebnega razgovora, koncept sodelovalne dolžnosti, vezanost organa na trditveno podlago prosilca, strogo presojo sodišč, dokazni standard in uporabo tajnih informacij v postopku, glede na kontekst pravice do izjave. V določeni meri obravnava tudi prakso slovenskih organov, kjer se v praksi ugotavlja, da ti ne sledijo v celoti razvitim standardom pravice do izjave in opozarja na nekatere zakonodajne pomanjkljivosti. Posebne pomanjkljivosti se kažejo predvsem pri izvedbi osebnih razgovorov in okoliščinah, v katerih se ti razgovori odvijajo. Magistrsko diplomsko delo opozarja na širši koncept obravnavanja prosilcev v kontekstu interdisciplinarnega pristopa in predlaga dosledno in celostno spoštovanje pravice do izjave v vseh stopnjah azilnega postopka. This thesis examines the content of the right to be heard, which forms an integral part of the asylum procedure. It focuses on its scope and substance, which is derived from primary and secondary European Union law. It expends this with the relevant case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Union, the European Court of Human Rights and the guidelines of some other relevant international bodies. The thesis analyses the procedural guarantees stemming from the right to be heard, according to the stage at which the procedure is at, taking into account the procedural dimension of the principle of non-refoulement. It discusses the conditions of the personal interview, the concept of the duty to cooperate, the obligations of the authority in relation to the applicant’s statements, the strict and rigorous scrutiny of the courts, the standard of proof and the use of secret information in the proceedings, all in the context of the right to be heard. It also discusses to some extent the practice of the Slovenian authorities, where in practice it is found that they do not fully follow the developed standards of the right to be heard and points to some legislative shortcomings. Specific shortcomings are evident in particular in the conduct of personal interviews and the circumstances in which they take place. The thesis draws attention to the broader concept of the treatment of applicants in the context of an interdisciplinary approach and proposes a consistent and comprehensive respect of the right to be heard at all stages of the asylum procedure. mednarodna zaščita postopek mednarodne zaščite pravica do izjave načelo nevračanja osebni razgovor sodelovalna dolžnost tajni dokazi international protection international protection procedure right to be heard principle of non-refoulement personal interview duty to cooperate secret evidence true false false U. Šelih Slovenski jezik Angleški jezik Magistrsko delo/naloga 2023-09-21 09:00:04 2023-09-21 09:00:08 2023-09-25 12:53:24 0000-00-00 00:00:00 2023 0 Ljubljana 0 Ljubljana 68 f. 0000-00-00 NiDoloceno NiDoloceno NiDoloceno 0000-00-00 0000-00-00 0000-00-00 1970-01-01 342.7:347.9(043.2) 114774 165510659 14563.pdf 14563.pdf 1 F90522F3766FC2BA15F38A5734137DD0 b3310b09b1f1bb0df912b6ed0c089c3837af533bd4e70f1cb3519ea0374773c2 81a2c836-584c-11ee-82e5-0050569b8976 https://repozitorij.uni-lj.si/Dokument.php?lang=slv&id=175268 Pravna fakulteta 0 0 0