Introduction
Accurate measurement of lower-limb alignment angles is essential for optimal planning and component positioning in total knee arthroplasty. The aim of this study was to compare coronal lower-limb alignment measurements obtained from weight-bearing long-leg radiographs (WLR) with reference three-dimensional CT measurements and to characterize systematic projection-related differences between the two methods. Secondary aims were to evaluate the influence of lower-limb position and anatomical factors on projection differences and to assess the impact of projection-related deviations on agreement in Coronal Plane Alignment of the Knee (CPAK) classification.
Methods
In this prospective observational study, 106 patients, corresponding to 187 lower limbs, were included. The arithmetic hip-knee-ankle angle (aHKA), medial distal femoral angle (MDFA), medial proximal tibial angle (MPTA), and femoral mechanical-anatomical angle (FMA) were measured on both WLR and CT. Projection differences (Δ = CT - WLR) were evaluated using Bland-Altman analysis and predefined outlier thresholds. WLR analyses included the double contour of the lateral femoral condyle and the rotational position of the femur during WLR acquisition, assessed using the FNPR index, whereas CT analyses included sagittal knee flexion, spinopelvic parameters, and torsional parameters. Agreement in CPAK classification was assessed using Cohen’s κ, and determinants of projection differences were analyzed using multivariable linear regression models.
Results
Measurement reliability was good to excellent, with ICC values of 0.76-0.90 for WLR and 0.80-0.95 for CT. Mean projection differences were +1.0° for ΔaHKA, +0.8° for ΔMDFA, +0.5° for ΔFMA, and +0.2° for ΔMPTA. Outlier frequencies were highest for ΔaHKA (13%) and ΔMDFA (10%) and were rare for ΔMPTA and ΔFMA. Limbs with a double contour of the lateral femoral condyle (18%) accounted for the majority of MDFA outliers. Redefining MDFA using the superior femoral condylar contour substantially reduced the number of outliers. Spinopelvic and torsional parameters were not independent predictors of projection-related differences. Agreement in CPAK classification between WLR and CT was 58% (κ ≈ 0.50), with discordances predominantly limited to adjacent classes.
Discussion and conclusion
Weight-bearing long-leg radiographs provide stable assessment of MPTA and FMA, whereas MDFA and consequently aHKA are subject to systematic projection-related deviations, mainly related to distal femoral projection artifacts, sagittal knee flexion, and the rotational position of the femur during WLR acquisition, assessed using the FNPR index. Pelvic incidence (PI) and torsional parameters were not independent predictors of projection-related differences and therefore did not explain the main discrepancies between WLR and CT measurements in this cohort. Consequently, CPAK classification on WLR shows only moderate agreement with CT and is sensitive to threshold values, requiring cautious interpretation for individual morphological classification.
|